A Sort of Duel by Noble Dust

Baden July 02, 2022 at 16:40 1800 views 28 comments
I walk down the stairs of the tube and I’m immediately hit with a weird smell, like a charcoal barbecue or something. Totally out of place. I almost wonder if I’m about to have a heart attack; I read somewhere you smell a specific smell before you have one; don’t recall the actual smell though. At my age it seams plausible. Anyway, I’m minding my own business and I sit down on the bench to wait for the train. Out of the corner of my eye I notice the guy sitting next to me and immediately get a weird vibe. He’s writing on a paper plate with a pencil. Not only that, he’s doing it pretty furiously, and his head keeps twitching from the plate to his right looking past me. He’s concentrating very intensely, stealing these furtive glances over. I try to play it cool and eventually turn my head in the direction he’s looking. Some homeless guy is slouched against a beam with an ornate notebook on his lap and he’s also writing furiously, but he’s using some ridiculous pen, like something a millionaire executive would have displayed on their desk. And he’s doing the same thing; he keeps jerking his head from the notebook to the guy sitting next to me, making these intimidating glances. Oh and by the way, the man sitting next to me with the paper plate and pencil is dressed in khakis and a polo; I think his shoes were recently shined. And, I kid you not, his hair is dyed blue; I have no idea why. It doesn’t fit his look at all. So they’re both writing and writing, getting more and more furious by the minute; blue-hair next to me is starting to breathe heavy like he’s shagging but out of shape which makes no sense because he’s very svelte. I’m sort of freaking out at this point, but some weird part of me wants to see what he’s writing so I oh-so-subtly just sort of cock my head to the left a bit and do a little side-eye thing but blue-hair immediately catches me and gives this possessed look, like “what the bloody fuck are you doing?” So I immediately furrow my brow, pretend I’m clueless, and whip out my phone and start randomly flipping through apps I never actually use. Homeless guy starts grunting. God, why? Now my blood pressure is rising because this is just way too weird. Maybe I’m actually about to have a heart attack. Out of the corner of my eye I see homeless guy doing the look-down, the look-over, the look-down, the look-over. He’s writing faster and faster, absolutely mental. Next to me I hear blue-hair’s pencil break. The heavy breathing suddenly stops. I can feel homeless guy freeze to my right. At this moment two trains come into the station at the same time going opposite directions. Blue-hair throws his paper plate down and legs it into the one in front while homeless guy carefully tucks his immaculate notebook away and gently strolls into the train on the opposite side. I’m sitting there in shock, forgetting that I was supposed to get on blue-hair’s train. The noise dies down, and the platform is empty now. I search for the plate but realize the wind made by the double trains blew it unto the tracks. I spot it. Now I’m quite literally on my knees, out of breath, squinting at a soiled paper plate, trying to see if I can make out any words written on it. Too far away. For some reason, instead of waiting for the next train I just leave the station and go back home. I called in sick.

Comments (28)

Benkei July 03, 2022 at 21:15 #715198
Paragraphs maybe? I have no clue what I just read. A duel as an analogy for what I just read doesn't bring any understanding.
180 Proof July 03, 2022 at 21:25 #715203
You really had me ... then "I called in sick". :confused:
Caldwell July 04, 2022 at 04:12 #715287
I grieved a little for this story because I really wanted it to go somewhere.

The writer successfully built up tension between the two men only to be interrupted by the trains that arrived. Then nothing after that. -- I want to know what's written on the paper plate as much as the writer does. :wink:

I realize I'm being literal.
ucarr July 04, 2022 at 16:11 #715444
Right now it's a fragment. I hope the author will build up the story.
Noble Dust July 05, 2022 at 04:44 #715673
I agree on the need for paragraph breaks. I kind of dug the weird vibe, though, but it was maybe a bit spastic.
hypericin July 06, 2022 at 01:56 #715893
Weird little story. It was effective in building interest in the reader for what was going on. Too bad it was then left unsatisfied.
Jamal July 06, 2022 at 06:08 #715972
The bad: this is not a story, nor even yet an idea for a story. It's a weird (in a good way) image that's been half-heartedly built up into a micro-narrative to try and meet the conventions of a story. The author was probably in a rush, and also forgot to break it up into paragraphs.

The good: it was absorbing, pleasingly weird and tense, engagingly written, and I wanted to find out more. If the author had started weeks before, and had made this a crucial scene in a longer narrative, I think it could have been a winner.
Jamal July 06, 2022 at 06:20 #715977
There was one thing that threw me off, and it's possible this is just me. It seems like the two scribblers are on the same platform, but then they get on different trains going in opposite directions, in which case they must have been on opposite platforms.
god must be atheist July 06, 2022 at 06:33 #715981
Reply to Jamal Continuity exception.
Benkei July 06, 2022 at 07:18 #715994
Reply to Jamal Not necessarily. In the Netherlands there are a lot of train stops with trains stopping at the same platform but going in opposite directions. The left side will be called "platform 1" and the right "platform 2" but physically it's the same one.
Jamal July 06, 2022 at 07:20 #715997
Reply to Benkei It's a recipe for disaster I tell you.
Jamal July 06, 2022 at 08:42 #716022
Another thing. I thought the present tense was successful, so I couldn't understand why it switched to past tense in the last sentence.
Hanover July 06, 2022 at 10:14 #716066
Quoting Benkei
Not necessarily. In the Netherlands there are a lot of train stops with trains stopping at the same platform but going in opposite directions.


Not sure what the train stops have, but your airport is filled with rats.
Benkei July 06, 2022 at 10:40 #716080
Reply to Hanover Better in the airport than in the House, Senate and Supreme Court. :razz:
Nils Loc July 06, 2022 at 17:32 #716178
It's obviously an allegory for America's political mess. The Libtard is dueling the Magatard on Twitter to no avail. The truth of the matter is that they are both disenfranchised and deluded folks, dreaming themselves into an American dream.




Baden July 06, 2022 at 22:31 #716288
I like the style and the pace/rhythm and the fact that the author is expressing himself spontaneously rather than trying to write a short story. That gives the piece colour and personality. So, respect the effort but the content doesn't grab me.
180 Proof July 06, 2022 at 22:48 #716294
Reply to Nils Loc :mask: :up:
god must be atheist July 12, 2022 at 01:41 #717895
I liked the journey so much, that the stolen destination did not bother me.

I enjoyed the flow, the acceleration of perplexed curiosity. I enjoyed the fact I enjoyed it. I mostly can't read.

I enjoyed reading it.

I enjoyed the tiny little surprises that movated me along to keep on reading. The blue hair, the acceleration in the frenzy of writing, the huge difference in financial cultural basis of the characters.

The ending was a cop-out, the author really should have thought of something better to finish it with. Although the heart attack theme was fitting to the character of the man.

Some people were arguing about how to access both trains from the same platform. In some cities the trains run on the right hand side of each other, but the stations widen out in the in-between domain between the tracks, and that's where the passengers gather, wait and move. In both directions the train opens its doors on the left hand side.
Jack Cummins July 14, 2022 at 22:12 #718870
I am wondering why it is written all in one long paragraph, and what point that is trying to make. It seems like a scene from something larger rather a complete story. I like the first person narrative voice and I would like to get to know the character further.
Jamal July 17, 2022 at 15:18 #719970
I just realised that this is very Lynchian. The intensity of mood and sense of mystery. And the blue hair, like the woman at Club Silencio, in one of the most intense and mysterious scenes in Mulholland Drive.
Noble Dust July 17, 2022 at 18:26 #720029
I had a much more intricate story idea pretty fully fleshed out, but ran into a wall when it came to the writing, so I whipped this flash fiction together in order to still participate.

I regret not breaking this into paragraphs, but the reason for it was to highlight the fever-dream pace. I'm not really sure where I would put them. If paragraph breaks are meant to give breathing room so to speak, there's no breathing room here.

Quoting Jamal
this is not a story, nor even yet an idea for a story. I


True. I have a running note in my phone called "Impressions", where I jot down interesting stuff I see. This was based on one of those; I don't remember exactly, but I think there were two different people writing while on the subway...I don't really remember the details, but in a world where everyone stares at their phone while riding the subway, it stood out. For some reason I imagined them somehow communicating through their writing.

Quoting Caldwell
I want to know what's written on the paper plate as much as the writer does. :wink:


It's interesting to me that this was a common complaint here. I guess it didn't even occur to me. I'm not sure what that says about me, lol. What's being written wasn't important to me. The point was to create an atmosphere.

Quoting Benkei
Not necessarily. In the Netherlands there are a lot of train stops with trains stopping at the same platform but going in opposite directions.


There's a lot of these in NYC as well. In my lame attempt to set the piece in London, I did wonder if these don't exist there. Oh well.

Quoting Jamal
Another thing. I thought the present tense was successful, so I couldn't understand why it switched to past tense in the last sentence.


In the spontaneous flow of writing it it felt right. Probably a mistake.

Quoting Nils Loc
It's obviously an allegory for America's political mess.


:chin:



Jamal July 18, 2022 at 02:39 #720165
Quoting Noble Dust
I regret not breaking this into paragraphs, but the reason for it was to highlight the fever-dream pace. I'm not really sure where I would put them. If paragraph breaks are meant to give breathing room so to speak, there's no breathing room here.


I think you can retain the breathless atmosphere even with paragraph breaks. It's not all happening in the same instant, so you can introduce a few breaks to mark the passage of time, like beats in the frenzied rhythm. I'd do it like this:


I walk down the stairs of the tube and I’m immediately hit with a weird smell, like a charcoal barbecue or something. Totally out of place. I almost wonder if I’m about to have a heart attack; I read somewhere you smell a specific smell before you have one; don’t recall the actual smell though. At my age it seams plausible. Anyway, I’m minding my own business and I sit down on the bench to wait for the train.

Out of the corner of my eye I notice the guy sitting next to me and immediately get a weird vibe. He’s writing on a paper plate with a pencil. Not only that, he’s doing it pretty furiously, and his head keeps twitching from the plate to his right looking past me. He’s concentrating very intensely, stealing these furtive glances over.

I try to play it cool and eventually turn my head in the direction he’s looking. Some homeless guy is slouched against a beam with an ornate notebook on his lap and he’s also writing furiously, but he’s using some ridiculous pen, like something a millionaire executive would have displayed on their desk. And he’s doing the same thing; he keeps jerking his head from the notebook to the guy sitting next to me, making these intimidating glances. Oh and by the way, the man sitting next to me with the paper plate and pencil is dressed in khakis and a polo; I think his shoes were recently shined. And, I kid you not, his hair is dyed blue; I have no idea why. It doesn’t fit his look at all.

So they’re both writing and writing, getting more and more furious by the minute; blue-hair next to me is starting to breathe heavy like he’s shagging but out of shape which makes no sense because he’s very svelte. I’m sort of freaking out at this point, but some weird part of me wants to see what he’s writing so I oh-so-subtly just sort of cock my head to the left a bit and do a little side-eye thing but blue-hair immediately catches me and gives this possessed look, like “what the bloody fuck are you doing?” So I immediately furrow my brow, pretend I’m clueless, and whip out my phone and start randomly flipping through apps I never actually use.

Homeless guy starts grunting. God, why? Now my blood pressure is rising because this is just way too weird. Maybe I’m actually about to have a heart attack. Out of the corner of my eye I see homeless guy doing the look-down, the look-over, the look-down, the look-over. He’s writing faster and faster, absolutely mental. Next to me I hear blue-hair’s pencil break. The heavy breathing suddenly stops. I can feel homeless guy freeze to my right. At this moment two trains come into the station at the same time going opposite directions. Blue-hair throws his paper plate down and legs it into the one in front while homeless guy carefully tucks his immaculate notebook away and gently strolls into the train on the opposite side.

I’m sitting there in shock, forgetting that I was supposed to get on blue-hair’s train. The noise dies down, and the platform is empty now. I search for the plate but realize the wind made by the double trains blew it unto the tracks. I spot it. Now I’m quite literally on my knees, out of breath, squinting at a soiled paper plate, trying to see if I can make out any words written on it. Too far away. For some reason, instead of waiting for the next train I just leave the station and go back home. I called in sick.


I think the lack of "breathing room", as you put it, comes across even more when this paragraphic rhythm is introduced, partly just because it's easier to read and thus less distracting, more transparent and direct.
Noble Dust July 18, 2022 at 03:04 #720175
Reply to Jamal

:yikes: thanks for taking the time to do that. It’s definitely way better. I suppose my lack of experience shows. Helpful feedback for the future, no doubt.
Jamal July 18, 2022 at 03:11 #720178
Reply to Noble Dust Yeah it's amazing how much better it seems to leap off the page and grab the attention. I didn't know the difference would be so great. Good to know.

I probably don't have this problem with my own writing because I obsessively re-read everything I write and couldn't do it very easily if it weren't broken up into digestible morsels.
Noble Dust July 18, 2022 at 03:39 #720182
Quoting Jamal
I obsessively re-read everything I write


Oh, same. I probably just also have ADHD. Weird combo.

Quoting Jamal
couldn't do it very easily if it weren't broken up into digestible morsels.


I can probably write endless blocks of text with no end in sight pretty easily. I've been known to do it here.
Amity August 09, 2022 at 07:37 #726961
@Noble Dust

Just dipping in to this scene and I think it's fab.
I really get the vibes.

'A Sort of Duel' - good title for the 2 sparring, aspiring writers.
Or maybe 3 if you include the author/observer waiting for the commute to a mundane job he hates.
Also, the 2 trains travelling in opposite directions.
Like @Jamal I had difficulty envisaging this.

Quoting Jamal
There was one thing that threw me off, and it's possible this is just me. It seems like the two scribblers are on the same platform, but then they get on different trains going in opposite directions, in which case they must have been on opposite platforms.


However, then I thought of Haymarket, Edinburgh.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haymarket_railway_station

As a general operating rule, trains to and from stations across the Forth Bridge tend to use Platforms 1 and 2, while those trains running to and from Glasgow and the West Coast Main Line make use of Platforms 3 and 4.

The station plan shows central platform serving trains to and from Edinburgh.
https://www.nationalrail.co.uk/stations-and-destinations/stations-made-easy/haymarket-station-plan

Also, interesting to consider the duality between East and West of Scotland.
Glasgow v Edinburgh. But that's another story...

Then again, colours can be important. I'm thinking of football teams and different religions.
Quoting Baden
And, I kid you not, his hair is dyed blue; I have no idea why. It doesn’t fit his look at all.


The creative type, an actor playing a part at a festival?
Or he maybe picked up the wrong tube. Wanted to be blonde.
And yeah, that's another thing...they're all guys!! Didn't go for opposing genders, then? Too obvious?

-----

Enjoyed the contrast between blue-hair guy with his cheap and disposable writing materials and apparently homeless but careful guy with his expensive tastes.
Blue hair legs it and homeless gently strolls, even after his furious writing of who knows what?

Quoting Baden
The noise dies down, and the platform is empty now. I search for the plate but realize the wind made by the double trains blew it unto the tracks. I spot it. Now I’m quite literally on my knees, out of breath, squinting at a soiled paper plate, trying to see if I can make out any words written on it. Too far away. For some reason, instead of waiting for the next train I just leave the station and go back home. I called in sick.


The observing commuter feels sick right from the get-go.
What kind of ailment? Physical, psychological, social anxiety?

Anyway, I think he's a lost soul. Perhaps he'll find his way. Without waiting for trains.
He has a need to read the writing on the plate.
A would-be desperate author?
There's a hunger for words but the daily grind might prevent creative productivity.
Except when there's a competition on! A sort of multi-dual fight to be a winner?
To succeed in touching a heart or mind...

Quoting Noble Dust
I can probably write endless blocks of text with no end in sight pretty easily


Scribbling furiously while waiting on the train?
Here's to light at the end of the tunnel :pray:

Thanks again for quite the ride :cool:


Noble Dust August 13, 2022 at 07:05 #728633
Quoting Amity
Or maybe 3 if you include the author/observer waiting for the commute to a mundane job he hates.


:chin: As usual with your commentary, I never thought of that.

Quoting Amity
However, then I thought of Haymarket, Edinburgh.


I love that train directions became so central to this story's discussion. :rofl: A product of me as a New Yorker trying at the last minute to set my story anywhere but NYC.

Quoting Amity
Also, interesting to consider the duality between East and West of Scotland.
Glasgow v Edinburgh. But that's another story...


I wonder who could write such a story... :chin:

Quoting Amity
Then again, colours can be important. I'm thinking of football teams and different religions.
And, I kid you not, his hair is dyed blue; I have no idea why. It doesn’t fit his look at all.
— Baden


I probably wouldn't have said this but for your response Amity, but I have no idea what the blue hair is all about. It just happened. I'm not sure if it helps the "story" or not.

Quoting Amity
And yeah, that's another thing...they're all guys!! Didn't go for opposing genders, then? Too obvious?


Eh, as I mentioned above, this little snippet was based on an actual moment I saw on the NYC subway where two men were both writing in notebooks. It was way less intense than this story, but both were men, and I'm a dude (as the narrator), so that's just what it ended up as. I drummed this ditty up at the last minute.

Quoting Amity
Enjoyed the contrast between blue-hair guy with his cheap and disposable writing materials and apparently homeless but careful guy with his expensive tastes.
Blue hair legs it and homeless gently strolls, even after his furious writing of who knows what?


:pray: Glad the irony was appreciated.

Quoting Amity
The observing commuter feels sick right from the get-go.
What kind of ailment? Physical, psychological, social anxiety?


I'll push back and say he only felt sick in that moment when he realized the absurdity of what he was doing. But it wasn't his fault; he was just an observer of a bizarre incident. It's like he didn't even realize he was kneeling down and trying to squint at a dirty paper plate on the tracks until he was actually doing it...and then he was just filled with embarrassment; reality kicked back in. He called in sick.

Quoting Amity
Anyway, I think he's a lost soul. Perhaps he'll find his way. Without waiting for trains.
He has a need to read the writing on the plate.
A would-be desperate author?
There's a hunger for words but the daily grind might prevent creative productivity.
Except when there's a competition on! A sort of multi-dual fight to be a winner?
To succeed in touching a heart or mind...


As always, you come up with interesting interpretations that I'm amenable to. But, I didn't think of the narrator as a lost soul; he's just a guy watching something really bizarre happen on the train; he's me, essentially, as I've seen countless weird and gross shit happen on the subway. Ask me later, anyone, if you want stories.

Quoting Amity
Scribbling furiously while waiting on the train?
Here's to light at the end of the tunnel :pray:


Haha, maybe I'm actually one of the duelers. As always, you kicked up some uncomfortable dirt.

Thanks for the comments, @Amity.
Amity August 13, 2022 at 08:16 #728646
Quoting Noble Dust
I wonder who could write such a story... :chin:


Hah. Perhaps a commuter waiting on a train at Haymarket...nah!

Quoting Noble Dust
I have no idea what the blue hair is all about. It just happened. I'm not sure if it helps the "story" or not.


It's a detail well observed. It gives the story colour and helps the reader remember who is who.

Quoting Noble Dust
...this little snippet was based on an actual moment I saw on the NYC subway where two men were both writing in notebooks. It was way less intense than this story, but both were men, and I'm a dude (as the narrator), so that's just what it ended up as. I drummed this ditty up at the last minute.


Reality is 2 men writing in notebooks. You noticed them in particular because you are a male writer.
Perhaps a bit like train spotting...not that you're a :nerd: or anything :razz:
All those invisible women...

I had difficulty trying to keep you as the narrator separate.
Sometimes I had you in mind, even though I don't know you.
Other times, I saw the narrator as a fiction...a figment of your imagination.
Strange how that works.

Quoting Noble Dust
Glad the irony was appreciated.

Yes, that was fun :clap:

Quoting Noble Dust
I'll push back and say he only felt sick in that moment when he realized the absurdity of what he was doing. But it wasn't his fault; he was just an observer of a bizarre incident. It's like he didn't even realize he was kneeling down and trying to squint at a dirty paper plate on the tracks until he was actually doing it...and then he was just filled with embarrassment; reality kicked back in. He called in sick.


I'll push back and say that his original sick feeling became worse. It intensified :razz:
I wonder what another observer would have thought when witnessing your reactions.
A woman's point of view.
When embarrassed by a public fall we don't tend to look at others, do we?
Just get up and look as if nothing had happened.
As you say, not his fault, nothing to do with me...

Did you call in sick?

Quoting Noble Dust
I didn't think of the narrator as a lost soul;


Of course not, he's you. Not the fiction I was thinking of.

Quoting Noble Dust
I've seen countless weird and gross shit happen on the subway. Ask me later, anyone, if you want stories.


Cue Comp 4?
I wonder if anyone else is so affected by the subway experiences and if they too write about them.

Quoting Noble Dust
Haha, maybe I'm actually one of the duelers. As always, you kicked up some uncomfortable dirt.


Oops :yikes:
Here's a sprinkle of glitter :sparkle: :sparkle: :sparkle:

Quoting Noble Dust
Thanks for the comments, Amity.


My pleasure. You know it :smile: