Why was the bannings thread closed to new comments

universeness August 19, 2022 at 08:47 6425 views 28 comments
Xtrix posts a poor response to his critics and then the bannings thread gets closed to any responses! :lol:
Xtrix says he gets angry sometimes, well news flash! So does everyone else. He gets to express his anger but if you are not a mod then you don't! The Monarchs always show their true bias in the end.
I was shocked to hear Xtrix say he would not miss his critics if they left the forum. :lol:
It's sad to read the typings of a moderator in full tantrum mode.

Comments (28)

Banno August 19, 2022 at 08:51 #730676
You don't like it, bugger off.

(there I got this in before the mods closed this thread.)
Amity August 19, 2022 at 09:05 #730677
If it were up to me, I'd ban the Bannings thread :naughty:

Drama queens, the lot of you!
Tate August 19, 2022 at 09:23 #730682
Reply to universeness Either stay and ignore it or drop this forum. Xtrix announced that getting an electric lawnmower was a good way to combat climate change. That's the intellectual level we're talking about here.
unenlightened August 19, 2022 at 10:18 #730694
Mods are not saints, but ordinary people who do a thankless task for no money by way of supporting a site they love. Nobody likes being criticised, and mods have to not only criticise but edit, warn and remove contributors that spoil things for the rest of us. In the end, the quality of the site depends on the contributors, and the contributors that remain are not always in agreement with the mods, but are at least tolerant of them.

To imagine that mods are power mad, or rampantly authoritarian or fascist is par for the course of anyone who becomes subject to their interventions, It not a fantasy to be encouraged, and so such discussions are cut short, for the mental health of us all.

Personally, if I have a concern about a particular mod, or a particular intervention, I raise it with another mod in private and wait patiently for my wisdom to be recognised. This sort of thread is unseemly, unproductive, and lowers the tone of the site. The concerns have already been expressed in the banning thread, and this is now just bitching about people who work for you for nothing, because they sometimes bitch too.

So just stop.
180 Proof August 19, 2022 at 10:29 #730696
Reply to universeness Quit your whinging ...

Valar dohaeris, dude. :smirk:
Metaphysician Undercover August 19, 2022 at 10:35 #730698
Quoting unenlightened
This sort of thread is unseemly, unproductive, and lowers the tone of the site.


I've got a great idea. Open a new thread to bitch about this thread. Then someone can open another thread to bitch about that thread, on and on, until the whole front page consists of threads bitching about threads, and the mods will have some real work of consolidation. Then the mods can demonstrate the true nature of the age-old metaphysical question of whether an infinite number of things can actually be consolidated into One.
Tate August 19, 2022 at 10:41 #730700
Quoting unenlightened
So just stop


Protest is actually a good thing. It means people care. Plus it actually does affect the moderator in question. When light is shed in his direction, his behavior improves.
Benkei August 19, 2022 at 10:53 #730702
Reply to Tate That's demonstrably false. Just look at most governments. :razz:
unenlightened August 19, 2022 at 10:54 #730703
Reply to Metaphysician Undercover Yes, that's a really good idea isn't it.

Reply to Tate Yes, protest is great. Have your say. That's what the feedback section is for. Use it also maybe occasionally to express support and gratitude; that's what I like to do a bit, when the more tiresome complaints are made.
Yohan August 19, 2022 at 11:27 #730705
Quoting unenlightened
Mods are not saints, but ordinary people who do a thankless task for no money by way of supporting a site they love.

Your love for the mods is heart warming. :heart:



praxis August 19, 2022 at 11:45 #730706
Quoting universeness
He gets to express his anger but if you are not a mod then you don't!


The recent banning of StreetlightX should put this rumor to rest.
universeness August 19, 2022 at 11:48 #730707
Quoting Banno
You don't like it, bugger off


Right back at you! What a great handle for an aggressive moderator! BANno!
javi2541997 August 19, 2022 at 11:52 #730708
Quoting universeness
BANno!


Dad jokes :rofl: :eyes:
universeness August 19, 2022 at 11:54 #730709
Quoting Tate
Either stay and ignore it or drop this forum.


To paraphrase an old song. 'Never promised you a rose garden, along with the sunshine, there has to be a little rain sometimes.'
universeness August 19, 2022 at 11:54 #730710
Quoting javi2541997
Dad jokes :rofl: :eyes:



Thank you my son!
universeness August 19, 2022 at 11:57 #730711
Quoting Amity
Drama queens, the lot of you!


Typed in full drama mode? Are you dressed accordingly?
universeness August 19, 2022 at 12:09 #730712
Quoting unenlightened
Mods are not saints


Neither are saints. They will never and have never went marchin in.
Saint is one of the most ridiculous titles ever invented imo. Probably a separate thread.

Quoting unenlightened
Personally, if I have a concern about a particular mod, or a particular intervention, I raise it with another mod in private and wait patiently for my wisdom to be recognised.

Do you think you are the only one who has tried this route?

I dont refute the value of site moderators, I am just participating in the right to reply or feedback on certain moderator behaviour, just like they comment and act on certain member behaviour.
I had clicked on the 'feedback' category before writing and posting this thread. I was surprised to see it appear in the main page of the forum. I must have neglected to choose some option or other. I am fine with it being moved to the feedback category if that would be preferred.
universeness August 19, 2022 at 12:14 #730713
Quoting 180 Proof
Quit your whinging ...


Don't be such a carpet! We don't all fold like paper when we think there is imbalance and the treatment of others is somewhat asymmetric.


Amity August 19, 2022 at 12:24 #730715
Quoting universeness
Typed in full drama mode? Are you dressed accordingly?


Of course :rofl:
universeness August 19, 2022 at 12:24 #730716
Quoting Benkei
That's demonstrably false. Just look at most governments. :razz:


Have protests never made governments uturn?
Have protests, civil disobedience, revolution, never brought down governments?
Were all past protests in history a waste of time and effort in your opinion?
universeness August 19, 2022 at 12:28 #730718
Quoting Amity
Of course :rofl:


:lol: :clap: Aw come on, post just one wee pic of you in full dramatic queen/king mode!
Perhaps you would even give the anti-lifers their first-ever genuine smile! :smile:

universeness August 19, 2022 at 12:30 #730719
Quoting unenlightened
when the more tiresome complaints are made.


You complaining about those who complain is equally tiresome!
Tate August 19, 2022 at 12:32 #730720
Quoting Benkei
That's demonstrably false. Just look at most governments.


True.

unenlightened August 19, 2022 at 13:01 #730728
Quoting universeness
You complaining about those who complain is equally tiresome!


That's why usually when it is the mods I complain about, I do it privately, and when it is other members, I use the report system to complain to the mods. I was an admin at the previous site for some years, and I have about seen all the permutations of overbearing mods and over-sensitive posters. I tried always to be polite in my fascist dictatorship then, but now I can afford to give the inner nagging auntie free rein. It's supposed to be tiresome, and send you to be with no supper.
universeness August 19, 2022 at 13:55 #730748
Reply to unenlightened
:lol: , Well, when you put it as pleasantly and fairly as that, it's hard to complain. Perhaps you would make a good moderator here, with the experience you already have. Perhaps your answer, if you were invited would be noooooooooooooo! or been there, done that! moved on!
After taking early retirement, offers to come back and help out as a supply or substitute teacher when needed have all been refused so far. Thankfully no wife, no kids etc so didn't need the money.
I loved teaching but I've been there, done that, moved on!
unenlightened August 19, 2022 at 14:24 #730764
Quoting universeness
noooooooooooooo!


That's about right!
T Clark August 19, 2022 at 16:05 #730778
Quoting universeness
Xtrix posts a poor response to his critics and then the bannings thread gets closed to any responses!


I was angered by Xtrix response on the bannings thread too, but I think Baden or whomever was right to shut that discussion down. I think the thread should be shut down sooner rather than later. It often turns into a ping-pong game of escalating vituperation.

A successful day - I got to use "vituperation" in a response. Say it loud it's like music playing, say it soft and it's almost like praying. Well, I guess not praying.
fdrake August 19, 2022 at 16:34 #730786
The bannings thread gets closed when the discussion in it ceases to be productive and about bannings. If I was paying attention I probably would have closed it sooner with a similar message to this.

If you have specific points of criticism about @Xtrix or any other mod/admin conduct, please make a thread about it here in feedback.

Closing the bannings thread is a different call (and I believe was done by a different mod) from any criticism you might want to direct toward @Xtrix 's conduct.

I'm closing this one now.