The Falconer by Noble Dust

Noble Dust August 06, 2023 at 02:45 750 views 31 comments
There are so many strange sounds in cold weather. Realities that don’t exist otherwise come into being when the temperature drops, and these invisible mysteries don’t obey the laws of acoustics. The snap of a twig as a creature moves through the underbrush takes on an alien quality and you’re not convinced it was a snapping twig, or that you really heard it. Sounds are far away and up close at the same time. The crunch of your boot under snow seems a mile away while the call of some beast across the valley sounds like it was recorded in an anechoic chamber. The voices of your loved ones become unfamiliar. Car engines are quiet while water dripping from icicles is deafening.

That winter Robin and I had talks deep into the night at our cabin and finally agreed to meet up with Heron and Ibis. We had resolved to find The Falconer. All autumn we’d been holed up, stoking the fire with the fir wood that surrounded us and drinking the beer Robin’s dad had made. I had hunted almost nonstop before the first frost and the freezers out back were filled to the brim with deer and wild boar. Yet by February, when daylight lasted 4 hours, our stocks were getting low, and we knew we couldn’t procrastinate any longer. The fatter we got on beer and red meat the lazier and more complacent we became. It took this nagging question at the back of our minds to rouse us: Who was The Falconer, and where did he live? Did he really have healing powers that worked at a distance? More importantly, Ibis had called us one night at three in the morning in a panic, telling us about how her daughter was deathly sick and how Heron had stopped eating in a comatose depression and we had to do something now oh my fucking god we had to move we had to find The Falconer if it was the last thing we did. I had tried to calm her down but knew it was no use, and knew that Heron was no use to calm his wife either. So with their daughter safely in the care of Ibis’ mother, the two of them left Coomb and set off for Deeping Hull where Robin and I were to meet them. We spent two weeks making boar jerky and sterilizing beer jugs so we could drink the stuff at room temperature, and set off in the jeep.

“You know, Merlin, I really have a hard time imagining Heron actually getting into that bad of a funk. I just don’t see it. He’s usually so, like...jovial?”

Robin looked at me with his typical side-eyed glance, neck cocked away from me. The muffled crush of snow under the ice-chained tires blended with his soft voice so I could barely understand him. I rested my right hand on the stick and leaned towards him, eyes on the road.

“I dunno, Rob. He can be bipolar like that. Remember when him and Grebe broke up? He didn’t answer the phone for days. We had to go to his cabin and practically break the door down and he was just sitting there in front of the stove staring at the embers and barely keeping warm. It took almost a month before we could pry him off the couch and drag him to the Sharp Shooter to try to meet girls.”

“Well, I guess. But Ibis exaggerates things. That’s why I’m still telling you I don’t think they should be together. I mean, I know they have a kid, the whole deal. But I knew they weren’t good for each other.”

“That’s just how things work out, man. Everyone you love ends up with people you don’t think they should be with. People are attracted to their own trauma. It’s like playing music. You convince yourself something sounds normal, something sounds good or right but in the back of your mind you know you’re out of key or you’re playing it wrong. But it has to be that way. If you actually played the notes right, their rightness would be jarring. Sounds can’t be what they’re supposed to be; people can’t be with who they’re supposed to be with. It’s like a learning process, you know? That’s what I realized back when I was writing all of those songs. A melody never sounds right; if it does, you get bored with it right away.”

“Well...maybe. You think about this shit way more than I do.”

“Stick to learning how to make beer, dude. I mean that as a compliment, I promise.”

“Yeah I know. I was surprised when you suddenly stopped all that songwriting, by the way. Speaking of Heron being kinda bipolar, you’re not, you know? You’ve always been so steady. Sure, I guess last winter you basically spent all your time hunting, butchering and writing, which was different. But I didn’t expect you to just stop the writing point blank. I never asked you what happened.”

“I dunno. I think it became an obsession. I became too enamored with the sound of my own voice I guess. It got to a critical mass that was sickening to me. I had to try to forget about myself as quickly as possible. Plus that was right around when Ibis told us she was pregnant. That changed something in me, I don’t know why. The world began to look and feel and sound different. It was kind of surreal.”

“The songs were good though. And you didn’t even record half of them.”

“I know. You just have to let some shit go, right? Pass me a beer.”

We made it to Deeping Hull by 2AM. Heron and Ibis were staying at the motel. We arrived and asked the desk clerk for their room number.

---------

“Oh my god guys, I’m so glad to see you.” she leans forward and fully embraces me, vodka fresh on her breath. I feel her chest heave and her skeletal breasts press into me. I feel the barely contained paranoia rattling through her scant body. She leans over and gives Robin a side hug and peck on the cheek. She steps aside and we move into the tiny room with two twin beds. It smells of moth balls. Heron is sitting at the edge of the far bed with his bare back to us facing the bathroom door. The walls are made of faux wood paneling. Heron’s body is positioned in a way that feels wrong. I cautiously step into the dim light from the bedside lamp. Some type of bugs are impossibly congregating around the light despite the sub-zero temperatures outside.

“Heron...hey bud.” I gingerly step over towards his gaunt figure. He doesn’t move. I turn around and look at Ibis. The desperation on her face sends a guillotine through me. Robin is hanging back by the open door. The room is quickly getting cold.

“Rob, shut the door sweetheart.” Ibis tries to speak in a motherly way.

“Ibis, we’ve got beer and jerky in the jeep. You guys thirsty? Hungry?”

“That sounds wonderful honey, I’m parched.” I block out the memory of her breath and walk back to the door to fetch refreshments. I hear Robin awkwardly try to make small talk with Ibis as I trudge towards the jeep. To be fair to Robin, none of us have seen each other since last season. Robin and I haven’t even met the sick kid. When I return with the cooler and jugs, everyone is in the same place they were in 60 seconds before. The air is tight and the sound of my feet on the lime green carpet is loud and unnatural. I grab tiny paper cups from the side table and pour everyone a beer. I leave the jerky on the bed that’s closer to the door. No one takes any. Heron hasn’t moved.

“So Ibis what’s wrong with your daughter?” I sit in the armchair by the TV and Ibis and Robin take seats on the beds.

“Oh god, we don’t know. She had fever and chills and night sweats and her urine was brown. The town doctor said she couldn’t do anything for her. And all tests passed with flying colors. An unknown disease or virus. She said nearly 6% of illnesses annually go undiagnosed. The symptoms point to something that could be fatal. She’s with mom, and the doctor said she’d call daily. I don’t know. I just don’t know, Merlin. I’m so scared, and Heron practically doesn’t exist at this point. It’s like I’m waiting for him to wake up. I’ve never seen him like this.” She looks over and puts her hand on his shoulder. He stirs slightly. Robin drains his tiny beer and looks at me for a refill.

“What have you heard about the Falconer, Ib?” He turns his body towards her from the other bed but she doesn’t meet his gaze.

“Just what we’ve all heard. He’s not so much a hunter as a gatherer, a gatherer of secrets and potions and remedies and shrubs locked inside the depths of this endless forest. That he speaks to no one but heals those in need, and that he does it from far away. They say he’s like the distant rumble of an avalanche. That he’s always lived out here in these woods, on these mountains. The things we’ve all heard our whole lives.”

She drains her beer and I fill her cup. She looks at me searchingly, longingly. Her gaze burns into my chest. I don’t know what to add, but I speak anyway, mindlessly.

“My grandfather used to tell the story of how he made the trek into the unknown and found only an abandoned campsite. He found strange markings, bits of dried flowers, weird frozen deposits of beeswax and pine resin, and a stench that cut through the bitter cold and was unbearable. Signs of healings or rituals or something. The legends run too deep to be completely false. He must be out there.”

“Yes...yes, he must.” Her eyes blaze as some drunken vision flits across her lids momentarily.

“What’s our plan?” Robin drains his beer again and I fill his cup. He slouches towards me to receive it.

“We sleep off the rest of the night and get started in the morning. I’ve heard we need to go on foot. I’m not sure how long the journey is. We’ll probably need more provisions. We’re running low on beer.”

“We get up when we can tomorrow, we gather information and provisions, and we go.” Ibis’ eyes pierce me.

“Yes”.

---------

By 2PM the next day everyone is awake, even Heron. The sun is beginning to set. Robin goes down to the desk to ask about our needs for the journey. Heron is unable to shower and Ibis has to wash him. She’s wiping away tears as the two of them emerge naked from the tiny bathroom. I turn, walk outside, and light a cigarette. I see Robin hurriedly walking up from the main office.

“The desk clerk said there’s one general store in town and it’s a half hour walk from here. She said The Falconer is a half day’s march due north on cross country skis and that the going is tough and it’s super dangerous. We can’t go by car. I guess he lives in a hut where the Coomb river branches out from the Drager. We need to start now if we’re going to make it and apparently there’s no guarantee he’ll even be there.”

“Ok.”

We duck back inside and the two of them are dressed. Ibis has her forehead pressed against Heron’s and they seem to be conversing at a low volume. They look up.

“Heron? Hey man. We’re here in Deeping Hull and we need to leave ASAP to reach The Falconer. We have to act now. For your daughter, man. We need to head to the general store in town for skis and more provisions. Let’s roll.”

Heron finally meets my eyes. He seems to understand. We move off, stock up at the general store, and head north.

---------

The woods are pure pine and we ski through in dusk as the way becomes denser and denser. Conversation dims as the cold creeps in. Knowing we need to find a balance of moving quickly and taking breaks to fill our bodies with protein and carbs, I try to gauge everyone’s feelings. Thankfully Heron has fallen in line and is skiing at everyone else’s pace, but I still worry for him. We come to a hill.

“Break!” We all collapse in the snow. Beer, jerky and preserved fruits from the general store are passed around.

“Ib, when exactly did you have your kid anyway?” Robin asks. “It was kinda sudden news for me and Merlin. We hadn’t realized you two were looking to have kids.” There’s an agonized pause. Ibis clears her throat.

“Only a year and a half ago. She was a surprise to us. A beautiful surprise, right Heron?” She taps his head like he’s a toy. He stirs.

“What? Who?”

“Our daughter, silly.”

“We don’t have...a daughter…” Ibis makes a funny face and gently slaps him upside the head.

“We need to keep moving.” I get up.

---------

The scant light is gone as we press on through increasingly tall drifts. No paths here but none of us are strangers to these conditions. We’ve all done this before. We here the howl of wolves, so much more high pitched than people know. Miles away yet they sound right ahead of us. Still gives me goosebumps despite years of hearing it. I begin to shiver.

“Anyone wonder why we even live out here?” I ask.

“We’ve always known these woods. Kind of a cruel beauty to it,” Ibis says.

“Yeah. I traveled south once. Came across some town. All of the people seemed miserable, ya know? Like they had no motivation. The cold moves us, energizes us up here. Makes us feel alive.” Robin the optimist. Sometimes gets old.

“Agree to a point Rob, but think. Aren’t we lazy too? And miserable? You and me just spent two entire months drinking beer, preserving meat, playing chess. All we did. What kind of life is that? At least now we’re doing something that matters. We’re doing this for...for Ibis’ daughter, right?”

“Right. For her daughter…”

“Guys, I’m beginning to shiver. Can we take another break?”

“Ibis if you’re shivering we keep moving. We’ll take a food and beer break in a sec. Er, I mean in an hour.”

“A whole hour? When did we eat last? Did we even eat before we left?”

“Course we did. And we ate an hour ago. I think.”

“Wasn’t it two hours ago Merlin?” Robin sounds haggard.

“No, it was definitely only an hour ago.”

Dark crowds in on us menacingly. Like walls of a cave that dwindle to an impassable point. Trees get thicker out here, pines feel sharper as they scratch coats. We don’t speak for a long stretch. All I hear is the huffing and puffing of Ibis, then Heron, then Robin behind me. Elk to the left running in the opposite direction to us, wisely keeping away. Animals are smarter than us. Or are they running towards us? Ears are usually keen but I feel disoriented suddenly.

“Do you guys here elk? Should we alter course?”

“No we’re fine. Not elk, just deer. Elk are loud. You should know that.”

“No they’re not, they’re...quiet. Right?”

“You can’t hear deer at all honey.” Ibis not very confident. Begin to feel a sense of fear that I never feel out here. Something’s been bothering me too and finally realize.

“Has anyone heard any birds...this entire trip?”

“Well yeah...or wait…”

“Weird...”

“We’re out here why again?” Ibis sounding weak. Surge of fear in me.

Heron trying to say something. No one listens. Getting pretty tired. Awkward silence lasts kinda long. Feel I should make conversation to keep energy. “Ibis what’s your daughter’s name anyway? Can’t remember.” Instantly embarrassed by lack of memory. Wish I said something else.

“Her name...is...fuck…”

“Wasn’t it…”

“She doesn’t have a name because she doesn’t exist.” A completely foreign voice. Panic. Look back. It’s Heron. Eyes lock.

“The fuck did you just say.” Everyone at a stand still. In a circle.

“I said Ibis’ daughter doesn’t have a name because she doesn’t exist.” Clear voice. Strong. Loud. Too loud. What.

“Heron...why you were so comatose...what…”

“Because you and your wife drugged me. To bring me out here and kill me. Robin’s the only one who doesn’t know what’s going on.”

“Honey, Heron. You...love...I really, but shud the fug ub.” Her balance wrong, kind of falls. Not shivering now.

“I’m not your honey and you don’t love me. And you’re not my wife.” She try to hit him with ski. Miss. I stumble at Heron, try pull out gun. Lights out, on my back. How long? Still dark but hint of sunrise. Get up. She on ground slowly taking clothes off. Bare buttocks in the snow.

“Honey what...don’t do...where’s the others…”

“Falconer behind you, look…found him. What’s carrying.” Nothing there. Turn around she’s taking off her shirt. Need to be alone. Panic now it’s just I don’t know what. Need to leave. Being need crawling away from her. Disgusting woman.

Found campsite. Snow cleared, lots of coals. Deer blood. Piss in snow. Old bucket. Carcass on the spit. No meat. Fuck you. Cold coals despair and laughter stiff legs just a nap

---------

I left those murderers in their hypothermic stupor. I didn’t even bother killing them. I just let them die because that’s what they deserved. I’m not guilty of anything. My name’s not even Heron; in fact, none of those cold blooded freaks were named after birds. They hypnotized and drugged me and subjected me to sleep deprivation. They knew I was a falconer; all the bird shit was for pure sadistic pleasure. They even convinced me birds didn’t exist. Fuck those fucks. Jesus. I fucking hate them. Those creeps knew everything about me. They must have been staking out my cabin for months. The kid Stephen, who they called Robin, is an innocent idiot so I took him with me and revived him, although he almost died, poor kid. I think they brought him out there to make it look like an accident. Or maybe they were going to kill him too. Lucky to have me with him.

It took us nearly six hours to get back to Deeping Hull, but we made it, checked back into the motel, and passed out. The next day I reported two missing persons to the Sheriff’s office. The girl at the desk took the report down like I was telling her I saw someone going five miles over the speed limit. Cute chick. Stephen had regained his wits and naturally had a lot of questions. He remembered that “Merlin and Ibis” were married but apparently was oblivious of their plot to kill me. He also seemed to believe The Falconer was an actual person, some kind of mystic guru I guess. I felt bad I had to dispel that one for him, like telling a kid Santa’s not real. What a mean thing to have to do. Oh well. Life is cruel. We’re addicted to our own weaknesses.

Comments (31)

javi2541997 August 06, 2023 at 20:01 #827657
It is OK. The story is very twisted because of the characters and its density and it becomes entertaining in the end, maybe the last five paragraphs. Yes, it is a good written story where the situation can change a lot, more than we maybe have expected in the beginning. Nice and good job to the author!
Jamal August 08, 2023 at 07:07 #828233
I liked this one a lot until Heron woke up in the forest and Merlin’s narrative broke down. From that point, it looks like the author abandoned the story and attempted to just wrap it up with a twist. But we were just getting to know the characters and the twist came far too soon, i.e., before anything happened; and the fascinating setting, which had been gradually revealed—I thought it might be post-apocalyptic—was suddenly dropped in what amounted to the it was all a dream trope. It also suffers from a lack of editing and revision.

I’m guessing that lack of time or writer’s block is to blame for all that. I reckon if the author had had more time it would have turned into a really interesting story. It was compelling and atmospheric up to that point in the woods, so I voted “I enjoyed it”.

EDIT: just noticed I did a “praise sandwich”!
Noble Dust August 09, 2023 at 05:30 #828547
The big reveal does seem to be the crux. I actually liked it but can see why others wouldn't. It's pretty jarring, and if it really does need to be how the story ends, maybe it can be done more smoothly. I don't know.

Overall I thought the writing was pretty good, but maybe a bit longwinded at times, or just too wordy. There did seem to be a good build up to the climax where everything went to shit. Pretty weird story. I go back and forth on the "big reveal" element. Not sure how to vote, as with many of these stories at this point, to be honest.
hypericin August 10, 2023 at 19:48 #829279
Not sure how I feel about this one. On the one hand it paints an effective (albeit a bit windy, as @Noble Dust points out), picture of a snowy world and four characters in a crisis. But then there is the ending. A good ending (including and especially a twist ending) flows from and is the fulfillment of what came before it. This one as @Jamal points out negates what preceded. A lot of long and specific writing kind of turns to ash.

Also, why the bird names? This was a distraction. I kept thinking, are these characters somehow animals? Like a previous story I can't remember now.
Jamal August 10, 2023 at 19:52 #829280
Quoting hypericin
Also, why the bird names? This was a distraction


It was a distraction only from the point of view of the ending. Before the twist, the bird names brilliantly conjured up a different kind of society. I loved it—I like birds—and was disappointed when it turned to ash.
hypericin August 10, 2023 at 20:02 #829283
Reply to Jamal I liked the names (and birds!) too, and the bird names seemed suggestive and important, but now I can't understand what they amounted too.
Jamal August 10, 2023 at 20:04 #829284
Reply to hypericin Yes, as I said in my first comment, I think the twist represents an abandonment of the story under pressure of time.
hypericin August 10, 2023 at 20:07 #829286
All that said, I liked the idea of the ending, I just wished it was joined to the story in a more artful way.
Benkei August 10, 2023 at 20:45 #829297
I was travelling along with the writer on the stairs as he build his story step by step. Then he tumbled down and broke his leg and I was left standing thinking "what the fuck just happened?"
Noble Dust August 11, 2023 at 06:20 #829421
Amity August 11, 2023 at 09:33 #829454
The Falconer

Who or what is a falconer, never mind a capitalised one?
I am informed that... and I would hide it but don't know how... :

wiki:Falconry is the hunting of wild animals in their natural state and habitat by means of a trained bird of prey. Small animals are hunted; squirrels and rabbits often fall prey to these birds. Two traditional terms are used to describe a person involved in falconry: a "falconer" flies a falcon; an "austringer" (Old French origin) flies a hawk (Accipiter, some buteos and similar) or an eagle (Aquila or similar). In modern falconry, the red-tailed hawk (Buteo jamaicensis), Harris's hawk (Parabuteo unicinctus), and the peregrine falcon (Falco perigrinus) are some of the more commonly used birds of prey. The practice of hunting with a conditioned falconry bird is also called "hawking" or "gamehawking", although the words hawking and hawker have become used so much to refer to petty traveling traders, that the terms "falconer" and "falconry" now apply to most use of trained birds of prey to catch game. Many contemporary practitioners still use these words in their original meaning, however.


Right away, we are drawn into a strange reality with senses heightened to the point of confusion.
Brilliant description:

Quoting Noble Dust
There are so many strange sounds in cold weather. Realities that don’t exist otherwise come into being when the temperature drops, and these invisible mysteries don’t obey the laws of acoustics. The snap of a twig as a creature moves through the underbrush takes on an alien quality and you’re not convinced it was a snapping twig, or that you really heard it. Sounds are far away and up close at the same time. The crunch of your boot under snow seems a mile away while the call of some beast across the valley sounds like it was recorded in an anechoic chamber.


The characters I eventually sussed out:
Robin (Rob) and I (Merlin) to meet up with Heron and Ibis (Ib) who have an ill daughter.
Aim: to find The Falconer who is not a hunter but a gatherer:

Quoting Noble Dust
a gatherer of secrets and potions and remedies and shrubs locked inside the depths of this endless forest. That he speaks to no one but heals those in need, and that he does it from far away. They say he’s like the distant rumble of an avalanche. That he’s always lived out here in these woods, on these mountains. The things we’ve all heard our whole lives.”


So far, so good.
Grateful that this long piece has been separated into 6 parts.
I might take a few shortcuts along the trail.
Heron appears to be the weak link in the party. Kinda not quite there...in any sense. Worrying.
In part 3, we see that he is unable to shower, needing a tearful Ibis to wash him.
What the hell is going on...

***

Part 4 - a deepening of the mood. Merlin leads the way in practicalities. Is he a legend, or what?
Heron seems to have recovered some equilibrium in this lovely passage:

Quoting Noble Dust
The woods are pure pine and we ski through in dusk as the way becomes denser and denser. Conversation dims as the cold creeps in. Knowing we need to find a balance of moving quickly and taking breaks to fill our bodies with protein and carbs, I try to gauge everyone’s feelings. Thankfully Heron has fallen in line and is skiing at everyone else’s pace, but I still worry for him. We come to a hill.


But then in an unsettling dialogue to answer questions about the daughter. The when, why, and how?:

Quoting Noble Dust
“Only a year and a half ago. She was a surprise to us. A beautiful surprise, right Heron?” She taps his head like he’s a toy. He stirs.

“What? Who?”

“Our daughter, silly.”

“We don’t have...a daughter…” Ibis makes a funny face and gently slaps him upside the head.

“We need to keep moving.” I get up.


Why does Heron deny that they have a daughter? Why was she a surprise?
Is he confused or trying to say that the daughter is...some kind of an alien? That might explain the strange illness?

***

Part 5 - increasing tension and darkness, even if none of them are strangers to the environment:

Quoting Noble Dust
The scant light is gone as we press on through increasingly tall drifts. No paths here but none of us are strangers to these conditions. We’ve all done this before. We here the howl of wolves, so much more high pitched than people know. Miles away yet they sound right ahead of us. Still gives me goosebumps despite years of hearing it. I begin to shiver.


Yes. Always scary the thought of a pack of hunting wolves. How different, though, are they from this current party? Hunting The Falconer.
However, I must say a picture of a howling wolf at moonlight...well, it fills me with awe. The loneliness.

The dialogue becomes that of pensive philosophers, questioning life and reasons for doing things.
Then, there is a disorientation as to time and how much has passed.
Until, silence and further deterioration of senses but the author kindly keeps us there and aware:

Quoting Noble Dust
Dark crowds in on us menacingly. Like walls of a cave that dwindle to an impassable point. Trees get thicker out here, pines feel sharper as they scratch coats. We don’t speak for a long stretch. All I hear is the huffing and puffing of Ibis, then Heron, then Robin behind me. Elk to the left running in the opposite direction to us, wisely keeping away. Animals are smarter than us. Or are they running towards us? Ears are usually keen but I feel disoriented suddenly.


Unbelievably, given their initial impetus to find The Falconer, there is a strange forgetting:

Quoting Noble Dust
“We’re out here why again?” Ibis sounding weak. Surge of fear in me.

Heron trying to say something. No one listens. Getting pretty tired. Awkward silence lasts kinda long. Feel I should make conversation to keep energy. “Ibis what’s your daughter’s name anyway? Can’t remember.” Instantly embarrassed by lack of memory. Wish I said something else.

“Her name...is...fuck…”

“Wasn’t it…”

“She doesn’t have a name because she doesn’t exist.” A completely foreign voice. Panic. Look back. It’s Heron. Eyes lock.

“The fuck did you just say.” Everyone at a stand still. In a circle.


Then, Merlin looks back at Heron whose voice has changed. Now clear and strong in denial of his daughter and Ibis as his wife. Increasing confusion, not just for the characters. Who is saying what and why?:

Quoting Noble Dust
“I said Ibis’ daughter doesn’t have a name because she doesn’t exist.” Clear voice. Strong. Loud. Too loud. What.

“Heron...why you were so comatose...what…”

“Because you and your wife drugged me. To bring me out here and kill me. Robin’s the only one who doesn’t know what’s going on.”


Heron accused Merlin and his wife (?Ibis) not Robin because he doesn't know what's going on. Ibis and Merlin attempt to attack or kill Heron. But they are taken down and out. Heron gone mad?:

Quoting Noble Dust
“I’m not your honey and you don’t love me. And you’re not my wife.” She try to hit him with ski. Miss. I stumble at Heron, try pull out gun. Lights out, on my back. How long? Still dark but hint of sunrise. Get up. She on ground slowly taking clothes off. Bare buttocks in the snow.


Who are the villains here, if any? It's all so confusing. Merlin recovers to find Ibis taking her clothes off. Why? Hypothermia?

Quoting Noble Dust
“Honey what...don’t do...where’s the others…”

“Falconer behind you, look…found him. What’s carrying.” Nothing there. Turn around she’s taking off her shirt. Need to be alone. Panic now it’s just I don’t know what. Need to leave. Being need crawling away from her. Disgusting woman.

Found campsite. Snow cleared, lots of coals. Deer blood. Piss in snow. Old bucket. Carcass on the spit. No meat. Fuck you. Cold coals despair and laughter stiff legs just a nap


Ibis warns Merlin that Heron is behind him. But she is confused and there's nothing there.
Merlin also in a state of confusion, panics, needs to leave, crawls away from 'disgusting woman'.

Which or whose campsite is found and by whom? Merlin, last person named? Could it be he has found The Falconer? Mounting mountain suspension and suspicion. Short sentences, barely conscious.
Wonderful ingredients...

***

Final paragraph:

Ah, so it was hypothermia. Diagnosed by Heron The Falconer:

Quoting Noble Dust
I left those murderers in their hypothermic stupor. I didn’t even bother killing them. I just let them die because that’s what they deserved. I’m not guilty of anything. My name’s not even Heron; in fact, none of those cold blooded freaks were named after birds. They hypnotized and drugged me and subjected me to sleep deprivation. They knew I was a falconer; all the bird shit was for pure sadistic pleasure. They even convinced me birds didn’t exist. Fuck those fucks. Jesus


Something doesn't add up. Drugged and comatose yet sleep deprived? Perhaps not the right kind of sleep. Is this Heron with full-blown paranoia, psychotic? Whose reality have we been a part of?

Robin is now Stephen, saved by Heron from Merlin and Ibis ( ? would-be killers now dead).
Heron's personality has transformed - the cute chick remark... seeing Stephen as a child.
Tearing his world apart. Not really sorry but being mean because life is cruel.
Heron is aware of his own weakness but doesn't mind his addiction. Revels in his nature.

Quoting Noble Dust
Stephen had regained his wits and naturally had a lot of questions. He remembered that “Merlin and Ibis” were married but apparently was oblivious of their plot to kill me. He also seemed to believe The Falconer was an actual person, some kind of mystic guru I guess. I felt bad I had to dispel that one for him, like telling a kid Santa’s not real. What a mean thing to have to do. Oh well. Life is cruel. We’re addicted to our own weaknesses.


There we have it. The Falconer doesn't exist. He is a lure to trap the innocent.
The idea of somehow being healed by magic is a powerful drug indeed.

***

I've been at this way too long. A weakness of mine.
But to add this:

Quoting Noble Dust
Everyone you love ends up with people you don’t think they should be with. People are attracted to their own trauma. It’s like playing music. You convince yourself something sounds normal, something sounds good or right but in the back of your mind you know you’re out of key or you’re playing it wrong. But it has to be that way. If you actually played the notes right, their rightness would be jarring. Sounds can’t be what they’re supposed to be; people can’t be with who they’re supposed to be with. It’s like a learning process, you know? That’s what I realized back when I was writing all of those songs. A melody never sounds right; if it does, you get bored with it right away.”


Is this the author's message?
A learning or realisation of a musician transmitted through writing?
Interesting. Thank you for the music, even if it jarred at times, it was never boring. I enjoyed it.
Nils Loc August 13, 2023 at 21:01 #830156
Not sure what transpired in this story as it began to go off the rails. Don't have the attention span to try to piece the details together.

The opening paragraph is brilliant (I concur) and inviting, paints an atmospheric mood.

I'm confused about what the narrator, Merlin knows and what he allows us to know. Does he come across as innocent and unknowing or is he really in on it. All the trouble is caused by Ibis who has concocted a plan to seduce her former husband, Merlin and kill off Heron. Why does Heron go along with it? He was amenable the entire time because he was drugged?

The naming scheme is strange too because it indicates Merlin as the Falconer (a magic man) where everyone else has the name of a bird.

Anyway, I'm still confused.
Jamal August 13, 2023 at 21:15 #830158
Quoting Nils Loc
The naming scheme is strange too because it indicates Merlin as the Falconer (a magic man) where everyone else has the name of a bird.


But a merlin is a bird too, a kind of falcon as it happens. And it’s Heron who says he was a falconer, in the last section. I didn’t really get what that was about either though. Probably just that he was a falconer in real life but in the mythology invented by the others, the Falconer had become something more grand.
Nils Loc August 13, 2023 at 22:43 #830173
Quoting Jamal
But a merlin is a bird too, a kind of falcon as it happens.


:up:
praxis August 13, 2023 at 23:18 #830175
User image
Jack Cummins August 14, 2023 at 08:39 #830242
I enjoyed the story but was a little disappointed when the sick girl didn't exist because I was interested in knowing her and her fate. Generally, the characters and the atmosphere of the setting seem well developed. The story has a surreal quality, with hints of shamanic states of consciousness.
Benkei August 14, 2023 at 09:13 #830251
Reply to Noble Dust Glad that made you laugh. But on a more serious note and for more clarification: I was sucked into this story, the bird names kept me wondering whether this was some alternate bird society instead of people. Even if that wasn't the case, having that nagging feeling in the back of my mind meant I was reading with more attention, to find more details. I think it's a clever "gimmick" to introduce something that is "out of place" but not in a "what the fuck's going on" kind of way to keep a reader interested. It's like a continuous cliff hanger "when is this oddity going to resolve itself?" It worked well for me.

I just think the ending was rushed/too sudden and terse in in its description. It was jarringly dissappointing because the rest was that good. Maybe that's too harsh but kind of the author's own fault for getting my expectations up (why we were ascending the stairs). And I was left wondering what to vote; the first part definitely warranted a "I enjoyed it" but the ending didn't. And since a at least one story managed to keep the level consistent, I voted "it's ok" even though that's not a fair vote compared to some other stories.
Tobias August 15, 2023 at 17:54 #830741
Quoting hypericin
Also, why the bird names? This was a distraction. I kept thinking, are these characters somehow animals? Like a previous story I can't remember now.


I also had that feeling... didn't I read a story where the protagonists were all animals before? They were drinking beer and doing animally things too... I have the feeling it is the same here. I loved the writing and the atmosphere, but concur with the others in thinking it might have been a bit more developed handing us a bit more information of what was going on...
Baden August 19, 2023 at 19:56 #831899
I concur with the general consensus that it feels like there's something missing / rushed / incomplete about the narrative. But...

Quoting Noble Dust
There are so many strange sounds in cold weather. Realities that don’t exist otherwise come into being when the temperature drops, and these invisible mysteries don’t obey the laws of acoustics. The snap of a twig as a creature moves through the underbrush takes on an alien quality and you’re not convinced it was a snapping twig, or that you really heard it. Sounds are far away and up close at the same time. The crunch of your boot under snow seems a mile away while the call of some beast across the valley sounds like it was recorded in an anechoic chamber. The voices of your loved ones become unfamiliar. Car engines are quiet while water dripping from icicles is deafening.


Quoting Noble Dust
That’s just how things work out, man. Everyone you love ends up with people you don’t think they should be with. People are attracted to their own trauma. It’s like playing music. You convince yourself something sounds normal, something sounds good or right but in the back of your mind you know you’re out of key or you’re playing it wrong. But it has to be that way. If you actually played the notes right, their rightness would be jarring. Sounds can’t be what they’re supposed to be; people can’t be with who they’re supposed to be with. It’s like a learning process, you know? That’s what I realized back when I was writing all of those songs. A melody never sounds right; if it does, you get bored with it right away.”


... these two paragraphs contain among the best writing in the whole competition and I've got to give this an enjoy vote in recognition of that. And I did like the bird names too. Weird and cool. Really looking forward to hearing more from the author.
Vera Mont August 20, 2023 at 04:24 #831977
I loved the first paragraph, too. Then the birds started doing weird things that made no sense to me, so I tuned out. I tried to pay attention to what was meant, who did what to whom, who needs what and why, but it just didn't jell.
Noble Dust August 22, 2023 at 19:29 #832791
There's a ton of great feedback here; thanks everyone, I'm super grateful. I'm a bit busy and need to get into the right headspace to discuss this, so it may come in fits and starts on my end. I'll see what I can do at the moment. I'll get to all comments eventually.

Quoting Jamal
From that point, it looks like the author abandoned the story and attempted to just wrap it up with a twist.


In hindsight I realize how bad the twist ending was, but in the moment of coming up with it and writing it I was actually really excited and had a ton of fun with it. The deadline definitely affected the decision to go that route, but I wouldn't say I abandoned the story just to get it done. I can see now how it reads as an abandonment of the entire narrative, though, which I'm very bummed about.

The main problem was that I didn't know how to end it because I didn't even really have a story in mind; as @Jack Cummins mentioned in his thread, I too have trouble with the "story" aspect of a story; the most important part. :lol: I'm more inspired to write by images or even just sentences that pop into my head. Then I'm left trying to create a story around whatever that is. For instance, this time around two things inspired this story:

1) The sentence "There are so many strange sounds in cold weather." This is simply a thought that came to me when I was walking home in cold weather last winter. I remembered @Baden mentioning writing a story by just starting with an opening sentence and seeing where it goes. I sort of gave that a shot this time; however,

2) I also have this note in my phone: "A story with human characters whose names are common bird names. They're trying to get to the falconer?"

That's it. Everything else that happens, the setting, the personalities (I hope) of the characters, all came into being as I wrote the draft. One idea was to have them never meet the Falconer and have an existential crisis of sorts, or to have them meet him and find that he's nothing like the legends.

Quoting Jamal
fascinating setting


Thank you. I quite like it too and might try to re-write this without the twist, or even turn it into something long form (very intimidating prospect).

Quoting Jamal
It also suffers from a lack of editing and revision.


Can you point to where you felt this way? I actually edited and revised it a lot, or at least as much as I could before the deadline.

I appreciate your thoughtful comments as always.

Baden August 22, 2023 at 19:43 #832802
Quoting Noble Dust
The sentence "There are so many strange sounds in cold weather." This is simply a thought that came to me when I was walking home in cold weather last winter. I remembered Baden mentioning writing a story by just starting with an opening sentence and seeing where it goes. I sort of gave that a shot this time


Interesting. Like I mentioned in the Shaun and Quigley story, the seed phrase was the first line, which I just got out of nowhere, far as I remember. Or maybe it was influenced by a TV interview, not sure, but there was no story. And here's the thing, there was still no story for a very long time. The original Shaun and Quigley meandered weirdly all over the place for literally years becoming a very obscure dreamlike narrative that reads like the disintegration of an inner personality or something. I don't even know how to describe it. But for the activity, I needed a story and I felt there was potential there, so I extracted 95% of what I had, focused on the first few paragraphs and tried to write an actual story from there. I was really stuck for a while and then one day close to the deadline, I got up from the table, got down on the ground, did 20 stomach crunches and the story came, or most of it. I don't know what point I'm making here except maybe while I like to write from a seed line and see where it takes me, it's no guarantee of producing anything. I just don't know any other way to write, I suppose.
Noble Dust August 22, 2023 at 19:46 #832804
Reply to Baden

Interesting. I like the idea of starting with a seed line; it at least feels freer than coming up with some grand narrative and then sitting down in front of a blank page and feeling overwhelmed. I've had one of those bouncing around since the first contest, and I still can't get myself to begin because the story idea is overwhelming to me. I started a "seed line" story last night actually; not sure if it will go anywhere but I like it. It's an interesting way to work, and feels more "musical" to me, so naturally I'm attracted to it.
Jamal August 23, 2023 at 13:41 #832971
Quoting Jamal
It also suffers from a lack of editing and revision


Quoting Noble Dust
Can you point to where you felt this way? I actually edited and revised it a lot, or at least as much as I could before the deadline.


I’ve asked myself the same question since I posted that comment. I’m not sure why I said that. I’ll read it again and let you know.

Edit: maybe there were some errors that you corrected?
Noble Dust August 24, 2023 at 03:05 #833208
Quoting Jamal
Edit: maybe there were some errors that you corrected?


I didn't make any edits once the story was posted.
Noble Dust August 24, 2023 at 03:06 #833209
Quoting Baden
these two paragraphs contain among the best writing in the whole competition


Thank you. :pray:
Noble Dust August 24, 2023 at 03:08 #833210
Quoting hypericin
A good ending (including and especially a twist ending) flows from and is the fulfillment of what came before it.


This is good info, thanks. I'm truly a dilettante.

Quoting hypericin
Also, why the bird names? This was a distraction. I kept thinking, are these characters somehow animals? Like a previous story I can't remember now.


See above. I don't know why they have bird names. I'd like to work on this more and figure out a reason for it.
Noble Dust August 24, 2023 at 03:09 #833211
Quoting hypericin
All that said, I liked the idea of the ending, I just wished it was joined to the story in a more artful way.


Any thoughts on how this could be done? Out of curiosity; like I said, I think I'd like to work on this more and get rid of the twist ending, despite having enjoyed writing it.
Noble Dust August 24, 2023 at 03:18 #833212
Quoting Amity
Ah, so it was hypothermia.


Yes, this was the funnest part of writing the end; the challenge of writing a first person present tense narrative that expresses the devolving state of increasingly severe hypothermia to the point of death. It was probably an exercise an inexperienced writer like me shouldn't have attempted, but damn it that was a blast. I think I got obsessed with this challenge and lost sight of how much this twist damaged the potential of the narrative up until that point.

Quoting Amity
Whose reality have we been a part of?


Good question. It changes when the narrative changes perspective, which is probably not a good thing. In my mind, Heron's "real" perspective as a near-victim of some psychotic would-be murderers is the real perspective. For what it's worth, if anything.

Quoting Amity
Everyone you love ends up with people you don’t think they should be with. People are attracted to their own trauma. It’s like playing music. You convince yourself something sounds normal, something sounds good or right but in the back of your mind you know you’re out of key or you’re playing it wrong. But it has to be that way. If you actually played the notes right, their rightness would be jarring. Sounds can’t be what they’re supposed to be; people can’t be with who they’re supposed to be with. It’s like a learning process, you know? That’s what I realized back when I was writing all of those songs. A melody never sounds right; if it does, you get bored with it right away.”
— Noble Dust

Is this the author's message?


You have a great eye as always. There is supposed to be a mirroring of this paragraph with the last paragraph, in particular these sentences:

"People are attracted to their own trauma."

"We’re addicted to our own weaknesses."

It's under-developed, though. Similarly underdeveloped is Merlin's comments about people being with people they shouldn't be with and this turning inside-out where we learn Merlin and Ibis were actually married, not Ibis and Heron.

Noble Dust August 24, 2023 at 03:19 #833213
Quoting Nils Loc
I'm confused about what the narrator, Merlin knows and what he allows us to know.


Yeah, this is a problem.
Noble Dust August 24, 2023 at 03:22 #833215
Quoting Benkei
having that nagging feeling in the back of my mind meant I was reading with more attention, to find more details. I think it's a clever "gimmick" to introduce something that is "out of place" but not in a "what the fuck's going on" kind of way to keep a reader interested. It's like a continuous cliff hanger "when is this oddity going to resolve itself?" It worked well for me.


This is cool, I'm glad you experienced it that way. If only I could figure out why they have bird names. :razz: